“How long should my novel be?” is one of the most common questions writers ask. To answer it with real books, I looked up the page count of the novels on the 2024 New York Times hardcover fiction and paperback fiction lists. The typical bestselling novel is 400 pages long, and the middle half run from about 350 to 465 pages. Fantasy runs longest, at a typical 448 pages in hardcover. Mystery and general fiction run shortest, at 350 to 370 pages. Fewer than one in ten bestsellers is under 300 pages.
Key facts
- Typical bestselling novel 400 pages
- Middle half of all bestsellers 352 to 464 pages
- Under 300 pages 8%
- 500 pages or more 16%
- Longest genre (hardcover) Fantasy and science fiction, 448 pages
- Shortest genre (hardcover) General and women’s fiction, 352 pages
- Sample 2024 New York Times fiction bestsellers
How long is a typical novel?
About 400 pages, if you measure the novels people actually buy. Across the hardcover and paperback editions that made the New York Times fiction lists in 2024, the median was exactly 400 pages. Most bestsellers sit close to that:
- Under 300 pages: 8%
- 300 to 399 pages: 37%
- 400 to 499 pages: 40%
- 500 pages or more: 16%
So three in four bestsellers fall between 300 and 499 pages. A shorter or longer book can still sell, but it’s the exception, and it usually has a reason, which I come to below.
What did I measure?
I read every weekly New York Times list for hardcover fiction and paperback trade fiction in 2024, from January 7 to December 29. Each list names 15 books and links to the edition that sold, by ISBN. I looked up each of those editions on Bookshop.org, which gives the publisher’s page count and the book’s subject codes, the industry’s standard genre labels.
I counted each edition once, however many weeks it spent on a list. I left out four Bridgerton volumes that bind two novels together and two short-story collections, and five editions had no page count listed. That left 280 editions of 267 novels. A book on both lists counts once on each because the hardcover and the paperback are different editions with different page counts. Deluxe and collector’s editions stay in when they were the edition on the list.
The genre is the first subject code on each book’s page. Those codes are the publisher’s own choice, and a few books could fairly sit in two groups.
How long is a novel in each genre?
Fantasy is the longest by a clear margin. The hardcover fantasy and science fiction bestsellers have a typical length of 448 pages, and almost a third of them run to 500 pages or more. Building a world takes room, and many of these books are the third or fourth in a series, where readers expect a long book and are glad to get one.
Romance comes next, then thrillers and literary fiction at about 384 pages each. Mystery is tighter, at 368 pages, and none of the 15 hardcover mysteries passed 432 pages. General and women’s fiction runs shortest, at a typical 352 pages. Danielle Steel pulls that group down: six of her hardcover bestsellers of 2024 sit in this group, and five of those are 256 pages long.
Table 1. Page counts of the novels on the 2024 New York Times hardcover fiction and paperback fiction lists, by genre. Typical length is the median. The middle half is the range from the 25th to the 75th percentile. Genre is the book’s first subject code on Bookshop.org. Two small hardcover groups (historical, 4 books, and horror, 2) are counted in the hardcover total only.
| Group (editions) | Typical page length | Middle half | 500 pages or more |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hardcover: fantasy and science fiction (30) | 448 | 412 to 536 | 9 |
| Hardcover: romance (26) | 408 | 336 to 468 | 3 |
| Hardcover: thriller and suspense (56) | 384 | 352 to 428 | 4 |
| Hardcover: literary fiction (18) | 384 | 332 to 428 | 1 |
| Hardcover: mystery and crime (15) | 368 | 336 to 400 | 0 |
| Hardcover: general and women’s fiction (38) | 352 | 300 to 436 | 4 |
| All hardcover (189) | 400 | 336 to 448 | 21 |
| Paperback: romance (47) | 448 | 384 to 576 | 13 |
| All paperback (91) | 416 | 368 to 512 | 23 |
Some groups are small, so read a difference of 20 or 30 pages as a tendency, not a rule.
Are paperback bestsellers longer than hardcovers?
Yes, a little: a typical 416 pages, against 400 for hardcovers. That isn’t because paperbacks print more words to the page. It’s because of which books sell in paperback. Romance makes up about half of the paperback list, and paperback romance runs long, at a typical 448 pages. One in four paperback bestsellers ran to 500 pages or more, many of them fantasy romance series such as Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Thorns and Roses and Crescent City books.
The books that lasted were longer too. The 43 editions that spent 10 weeks or more on a list in 2024 had a typical length of 416 pages, and none was under 300 pages. The same is true of the 40 editions that reached No. 1, at a typical 432. A long book doesn’t sell because it’s long. But readers who love a series or an author clearly don’t mind a big book.
How short or long can a bestselling novel be?
Shorter than you might think, and much longer. The shortest hardcover bestseller of 2024 was Claire Keegan’s Small Things Like These, at 128 pages, followed by Gabriel García Márquez’s Until August at 144 pages and T. Kingfisher’s What Feasts at Night at 160 pages. The longest was Brandon Sanderson’s Wind and Truth, at 1,344 pages, followed by Greg Iles’s Southern Man at 976 pages.
Those are real exceptions, and each has a reason. Keegan’s book is a prize-shortlisted novella from an established literary author. Sanderson’s is the fifth book in an epic fantasy series with a famously devoted readership. An unknown author with a 1,300-page first novel faces a much harder sell than Sanderson does.
How many words is a novel?
Publishers don’t print word counts, which is why I measured pages. And a printed page isn’t a manuscript page. A standard double-spaced manuscript page holds about 250 words, while a printed page holds more or fewer depending on the trim size, the typeface, and the spacing the designer chooses. The same text can make a very different number of pages in a small paperback and a large hardcover. My guide to book sizes explains how trim size changes the page count.
So use the page counts above to compare your book with others in your genre, not as a word target. When you send a novel to an agent or publisher, they’ll ask for a word count, and their own submission guidelines are the place to check what they expect for your genre.
What does this mean for your novel?
- Find your genre’s range. Look up the page counts of five or six recent books like yours, in the same format. If yours would print far outside that range, ask why.
- Be careful at the extremes. A very long book has to keep its pace for every page, and a very short one has to feel complete. Both are harder to sell from a new author.
- Don’t pad, and don’t cut blindly. Length should come from the story. A novel that’s long because of repeated scenes needs cutting. A novel that’s short because the middle is thin needs building, not stretching.
- Think about cost if you’re self-publishing. More pages mean a higher printing cost per copy and a higher price, which matters most in genres where readers expect a lower price.
Whether a book is the right length is a structural question, so it’s one of the first things a developmental editor looks at. My guide to developmental editing explains what that edit covers and what it costs.
Frequently asked questions
How many pages is a typical novel?
The typical bestselling novel on the 2024 New York Times fiction lists was 400 pages long, and three in four were between 300 and 499 pages.
How long is a fantasy novel?
Longer than most. Hardcover fantasy and science fiction bestsellers had a typical length of 448 pages in 2024, and almost a third ran to 500 pages or more.
How long is a romance novel?
The typical romance bestseller was 408 pages in hardcover and 448 pages in paperback. Fantasy romance series push the paperback figure up.
How long is a thriller or a mystery?
Thrillers had a typical length of 384 pages in hardcover, and mysteries 368 pages. Mystery was the most consistent genre: no hardcover mystery on the lists passed 432 pages.
Can a novel be too short?
It can feel too short for its genre, but length alone doesn’t decide it. Only 8% of the 2024 bestsellers were under 300 pages. Six of those are Danielle Steel novels, and several others are short literary novels or holiday stories, almost all by well-known authors.
Is a 500-page novel too long?
Not for fantasy or a long romance series, where about three in ten bestsellers run to 500 pages or more. In mystery or general fiction, 500 pages is far above the norm, and an editor would ask whether the story needs it.
How do I convert my word count to pages?
Your typesetter or layout program can tell you exactly for a given trim size and typeface. A double-spaced manuscript page holds about 250 words, but a printed page can hold more or fewer, so don’t compare manuscript pages with printed ones.
Source: The weekly New York Times bestseller lists for hardcover fiction and paperback trade fiction dated January 7 through December 29, 2024, with page counts and subject codes for each listed edition from Bookshop.org, read November 12, 2026.
Not sure your novel is the right length? A developmental edit looks at the whole structure of your book, including where it runs long and where it needs more. Get in touch here.