Editorial reviews are the short quotations from professional reviewers, publications, and other authors that appear on a book’s cover, in its front pages, and in the Editorial Reviews section of its Amazon page. They’re not customer reviews; they’re praise the publisher or author collects and chooses. To see what that praise looks like on traditionally published books, I read the publisher’s own praise for 88 recent titles: this year’s contenders for two American fiction prizes, and the 59 books on The New York Times’s fiction lists over four recent weeks. The most quoted sources are four magazines that review books before publication: Booklist, Publishers Weekly, Kirkus Reviews, and Library Journal. Thirty-seven of the 49 bestsellers with praise of their own quote at least one of them. Self-published authors can reach most of them, but only through early submission, a fee, or both.
Key facts
- Bestsellers quoting a trade review magazine 37 of 49 with praise for the book itself
- Prize-listed books quoting one 23 of 29
- Most quoted Booklist, on 25 bestsellers and 18 prize-listed books
- Free submission lead time Library Journal, six months before publication; Booklist, four to six months
- Publishers Weekly $25 to be considered, no review guaranteed, 12 weeks or longer
- Paid reviews BookLife $399, Kirkus Indie from $450, Foreword Clarion $579
- Amazon Authors add editorial reviews through Author Central, a US-only feature
What are editorial reviews?
They’re professional opinions of a book, quoted to help sell it. A line from a review magazine, a newspaper, or a well-known author goes on the back cover, on a praise page inside the book, on the publisher’s website, and in the Editorial Reviews section of the book’s Amazon page. Readers see them as a stranger’s honest verdict, and at their best they are.
Editorial reviews differ from customer reviews in one important way: someone chooses them. A publisher, or a self-published author, picks the strongest lines from the reviews a book has received and presents them in the best order. Customer reviews, the star ratings readers post on Amazon or Goodreads, are written by anyone who reads the book, and nobody gets to select them.
What do traditional publishers quote in their editorial reviews?
Trade review magazines, the press, and other authors. Publishers supply this praise with each book’s listing, and Bookshop.org shows it on each book’s page under “Reviews.” I read it for two groups of books. The first is every contender this year for the National Book Award for Fiction and The Center for Fiction’s First Novel Prize, 29 titles in all. The second is every one of the 59 books that made the Times’s hardcover and paperback fiction lists between September 20 and October 11, 2026. I counted only praise for the book itself. Many established authors’ pages also quote reviews of their earlier books.
Table 1. Trade review magazines quoted in the publisher’s own praise, by book. Read on Bookshop.org, October 5, 2026.
| Outlet quoted | Prize-listed books (29) | Bestsellers with praise for the book (49) |
|---|---|---|
| Booklist | 18 | 25 |
| Publishers Weekly | 17 | 21 |
| Kirkus Reviews | 16 | 21 |
| Library Journal | 3 | 17 |
| BookPage | 2 | 6 |
| Shelf Awareness | 3 | 3 |
| Booklist, Publishers Weekly, Kirkus, or Library Journal | 23 | 37 |
The typical book in each group quotes 11 to 13 sources in all. Besides the trade magazines, they include newspapers and magazines, such as The New York Times and The New Yorker, and fellow authors. Ten of the 59 bestsellers showed no praise for the book itself on Bookshop.org: seven had no praise section at all, and three quoted only reviews of the author’s earlier books.
Which review outlets matter most for a book?
The four that review books before they come out: Booklist, Publishers Weekly, Kirkus Reviews, and Library Journal. Booklist is published by the American Library Association, and Library Journal writes for librarians, so a good review in either one helps a book into libraries. Publishers Weekly and Kirkus cover the whole trade, from literary fiction to thrillers to business books, and 30 of the 49 bestsellers quote one or both.
Their reviews are short, and they’re not all positive. Library Journal says plainly that its reviews “are both positive and negative.” That’s what gives a good one its value. Each magazine also gives a star to the books it singles out, and publishers name the star in the quotation, as in “Booklist, starred review.” In this group, Publishers Weekly gave stars to 12 of the prize-listed books, and Booklist to 12 of the bestsellers.
Newspaper reviews and author blurbs matter too, but they arrive later or depend on connections. The trade magazines are the one place a new author can earn independent praise before publication.
Can self-published authors get reviews from the same outlets?
Yes, but the doors are narrower. Each of the four has its own policy:
- Booklist says it “carefully” considers self-published titles that meet its criteria but warns that it “cannot cover this fast-growing segment as thoroughly as we wish.” It points self-published authors to its partner, BlueInk Review.
- Publishers Weekly takes submissions from self-published authors through its BookLife site. Every book submitted for review consideration, from any publisher, now carries a $25 fee, and Publishers Weekly says that “a small percentage of books submitted will be reviewed.”
- Kirkus Reviews runs a separate paid program, Kirkus Indie, for self-published authors.
- Library Journal reviews books “of national interest” from galleys received six months before publication, and says it generally avoids reviewing books after their publication date.
Foreword Reviews, a magazine that covers independent and self-published books, also takes free submissions of new and forthcoming titles for its magazine, and runs a paid review service, Clarion, for books it doesn’t choose.
Should you pay for an editorial review?
Sometimes, and only for a book that’s ready. Paid reviews from established names are written by professional reviewers, and none of them promises praise. Kirkus says it does “not guarantee positive reviews,” though an unfavorable indie review doesn’t have to be published. What you’re buying is a guaranteed reading, a review you can quote if it’s good, and a delivery date.
Table 2. Routes to a trade review for a self-published book, with cost and timing as each outlet states them. Read on each outlet’s website, October 5, 2026.
| Route | Cost | Timing | Review guaranteed? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Publishers Weekly, through BookLife | $25 submission fee | 12 weeks or longer | No |
| BookLife Review (Publishers Weekly’s indie service) | $399 | Within 6 weeks, or 4 expedited | Yes |
| Kirkus Indie traditional review, 250 words | From $450, or $599 expedited | 7 to 9 weeks | Yes, but not a positive one |
| Kirkus Indie expanded review, about 500 words | From $599 | 7 to 9 weeks | Yes, but not a positive one |
| Foreword Reviews magazine | Free | Before or just after publication | No |
| Foreword Clarion Review | $579 | Not listed on its page | Yes |
| Booklist | Free | Submit 4 to 6 months before publication | No |
| Library Journal | Free | Submit 6 months before publication | No |
A paid review makes the most sense for a book aimed at libraries, bookstores, or prize committees, where a recognized name carries weight, and for an author with time before launch to use the quote well. It also helps nonfiction by a first-time author, where a professional reviewer’s view of the book’s authority answers a reader’s first question: why should I trust this writer? It makes the least sense for a book that hasn’t been professionally edited because a reviewer who’s paid to be honest will say so in print.
When should you send your book out for review?
Months before publication. The free routes are built around advance copies: Library Journal wants them six months ahead, Booklist four to six months ahead, and a Publishers Weekly decision can take 12 weeks or more. Even the paid services need four to nine weeks. A review that arrives after launch can still go on your Amazon page, but it misses the cover, the press materials, and the preorder period.
So plan backward from your publication date. To reach the trade magazines, the book needs to be edited, proofread, and laid out as an advance copy four to six months before it goes on sale. That’s one of the main reasons a self-published schedule takes longer than most first-time authors expect.
Here’s what that looks like for a book going on sale on June 1. Each date is the latest that meets the outlet’s stated timing, so earlier is safer.
Table 3. Working back from a June 1 publication date, using each outlet’s stated lead time.
| Deadline | What has to happen |
|---|---|
| December 1 | Advance copy to Library Journal, 6 months ahead |
| December 1 to February 1 | Advance copy to Booklist, 4 to 6 months ahead |
| Early March | Submission to Publishers Weekly, which can take 12 weeks or longer |
| Late March | Order a Kirkus Indie review, 7 to 9 weeks |
| Mid-April | Order a BookLife Review, within 6 weeks |
Read the first line of that table again. A December advance copy means the copy edit and proofread are finished in the fall, which means the manuscript itself is done by late summer.
How do you add editorial reviews to an Amazon book page?
Through Amazon Author Central, Amazon’s free service for authors. Amazon’s publishing help lists “Add Editorial Reviews for your books” among the things Author Central does, and notes that it’s a US-only feature. You sign up with your Kindle Direct Publishing account, claim your books, and add the reviews to each book from there.
Keep each one short and accurate. Quote the strongest sentence or two, attribute it exactly as the source wrote it, such as “Kirkus Reviews” or “Booklist, starred review,” and never trim a quotation in a way that changes its meaning. Put your best source first because it’s the line most readers see.
What about blurbs from other authors?
They’re the most common kind of praise after the magazines. Of the 29 prize-listed books, 25 quote at least one other author, and 13 quote six or more. For a debut, a blurb from an established writer in the same genre tells readers where the book belongs.
Blurbs come through relationships, so start early. Ask authors whose work genuinely resembles yours, through a mutual contact if you can, and give them at least two months and a finished, proofread copy. Never pay for a blurb, and never offer one in exchange for another.
A good request is short and easy to say yes to:
- Say why you’re asking this author, in one sentence that shows you know their work.
- Describe the book in two or three sentences, the way its back cover will.
- Give a clear deadline, tied to your printing date.
- Offer the format they prefer, a PDF, an ebook file, or a printed advance copy.
- Make it easy to decline, and thank them either way. A gracious ask keeps the door open for the next book.
When a blurb arrives, quote it exactly, with the author’s name and their best-known book, as the publishers in this study do.
Is your book ready to send to reviewers?
It needs to be the finished book, edited and proofread. BookLife warns that self-published submissions are judged “by the same professional standards that Publishers Weekly applies to traditionally published books.” A reviewer won’t excuse typos, inconsistencies, or a slow first chapter because the author published it alone. Those problems can end up in the review itself.
That’s why editing comes first in any review plan. A copy edit and a proofread catch the errors that would undercut a good review. If the book’s structure or pace is in doubt, a manuscript evaluation or developmental edit needs to come well before that.
Frequently asked questions
Are editorial reviews the same as customer reviews?
No. Editorial reviews are quotations chosen by the publisher or author from professional sources. Customer reviews are posted by readers, and the author has no control over them.
Can I pay readers to review my book on Amazon?
No. Amazon’s help pages say you may give readers free or discounted copies, as long as you don’t require a review or try to influence it. Offering anything more, such as gift cards, invalidates the review, and Amazon removes it.
How many editorial reviews does a book need?
The traditionally published books I looked at quote 11 to 13 sources in a typical case. A self-published book doesn’t need that many. Three strong, attributed quotations, one of them from a recognized outlet if possible, do more than a long list of weak ones.
What is a starred review?
A star that a trade magazine adds to a review of a book it considers exceptional. Publishers include it in the quotation, as in “Kirkus Reviews, starred review.”
Can I get a review after my book is published?
From some outlets. BookLife accepts books that are available or about to be available, and Kirkus Indie is open to unpublished and self-published authors. Library Journal and Booklist work almost entirely before publication.
Should I put editorial reviews inside the book?
If you have them, yes, on a praise page at the front. The Chicago Manual of Style puts that page first, before the half title, so a reader who opens the book meets the quotations before anything else.
Do the trade magazines review books that aren’t for libraries?
Yes. Publishers Weekly and Kirkus review every kind of trade book, and 30 of the 49 bestsellers I looked at quote one or both.
The longlists are at the National Book Foundation and The Center for Fiction. Submission terms are from BookLife, Kirkus Indie, Foreword, Booklist, and Library Journal. Prices change, so check each one before you order.
Planning to send your book to reviewers? Make sure it’s the book you want reviewed. My copy editing and proofreading catch the errors a reviewer would notice, and my free self-publishing services consult covers review requests and timing, so your advance copies go out on schedule. Get in touch here.